The Ultimate Guide to Shingle Roofing (Pros & Cons)

If you're looking for a new roof for your property, consider a shingle roof replacement. You should shingle your roof when you notice pieces missing or signs of wear and tear, usually a few decades after installation. This guide can help you discover why shingle roofs may be a good choice for your home.

Pros of asphalt shingle roofs

Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingle Roofs

Asphalt shingle roofs are good, low-maintenance and cost-effective options that can guard your property against the elements. Consider the following advantages of installing this type of roofing on your house:

  • Inexpensive: Since this material is so popular, asphalt shingle roofing is readily available. This means the manufacturing and distribution cost of asphalt shingles?tends to be cheaper.
  • Fire resistant: Fiberglass asphalt shingles can prevent a fire from spreading inside or outside a building.
  • Moisture resistant: Asphalt shingles, such as our products treated with Scotchguard Shingle Protector, can withstand moisture damage and algae buildup.
  • Versatile: Our Owens Corning shingles come in several colors, styles and sizes to provide an aesthetically pleasing shingle that enhances your home's curb appeal.
  • Easy to install: The process of applying asphalt shingles to a roof is straightforward because they are lightweight and easy to cut.
  • Low maintenance: Asphalt roof shingles are low maintenance because they're easy to repair or replace if they are damaged.

On the other hand, consider the disadvantages of shingle roofs made from asphalt:

  • Vulnerable to weather damage: Asphalt shingles are more likely to crack and fade in extreme heat, and they'll expand and contract when the temperature fluctuates throughout the year. In windy areas, the pieces can pull up from the roof during harsh storms.
  • You can only install them in warm temperatures: If you set shingles up in freezing temperatures, your roofing can become damaged. You'd need to wait until the spring or summer to replace your roof, which could leave your home vulnerable to pests and other damage if you have gaps in your shingles.
  • Not safe for the environment: During the asphalt manufacturing process, factories waste energy and produce harmful greenhouse gas emissions. Asphalt shingles also aren't as easy to recycle as metal or wood pieces.

Pros and Cons of Cedar Shingles

Cedar wood shingles have been around for a long time, and they come with the following benefits for your home:

  • Aesthetically pleasing: Cedar roofs have a timeless appearance that other materials seek to emulate during the manufacturing process.
  • Environmentally friendly: Since cedar shingles are organic, biodegradable and recyclable, they're the most eco-friendly roofing option for your property.
  • Energy efficient: Wood is a natural insulator, so your shingles can help regulate your interior living space's temperature and reduce your utility costs.

However, consider some of the drawbacks of cedar shingles:

  • Challenging to install: Applying and replacing cedar shingles require professional help because the process is challenging and expensive.
  • High maintenance:?Cedar shingles can be challenging to maintain, and instead of replacing one or two shingles like you can do with asphalt shingles, you often have to replace the whole roof.
  • Expensive:?Even though cedar shingles tend to have an affordable upfront cost, their complicated installation and high maintenance requirements drive up their overall price.
  • Prone to fire and insect damage:?Cedar shingles tend to last several decades, about the same life span as asphalt shingles. However, wooden shingles are highly flammable, and they're vulnerable to termites and other pests that eat moist wood.

Pros and Cons of Metal Shingles

Metal shingles are a unique, modern option for your roof. Here are some of the benefits of this roof shingle material:

  • Useful for flat roofs:?Due to their durability, metal shingles can better accommodate flat or highly steep rooflines than other shingle materials.
  • Long lasting: Metal roofs tend to last more than half a century and can withstand weather and impact damage.
  • Energy efficient: Since metal shingles can reflect sunlight and heat, the inside of your home tends to maintain a more pleasant temperature throughout the day, reducing your need to use your HVAC system.
  • Light: Installing, repairing and replacing metal shingles is convenient because of their light weight.
  • Fire resistant: Metal doesn't combust when exposed to fire inside or outside of the house.
  • Environmentally friendly: Metal shingles are recyclable and easy to install over an existing roof.

Metal shingles also feature the following drawbacks:

  • Noisy: When it rains or hails, the precipitation bounces off the roof and makes loud noises.
  • Expensive: Metal shingles have a high upfront and installation cost.

Pros and Cons of Slate Shingles

Slate shingles are a unique addition to your roof because of the following benefits:

  • Longest lasting: Slate shingles are resistant to heat, hail and moisture. They're also fireproof and unlikely to leak. As a result, they can last up to a century, making them the longest-lasting roof shingles.
  • Resistant to snow and moisture damage: Since they can withstand large volumes of snow, they tend to be popular in places that get a lot of precipitation throughout the year.
  • Naturally beautiful: The rock products within your slate shingles provide various natural color options that can complement your home's aesthetic.

Here are some of the drawbacks of purchasing and installing slate shingles:

  • Expensive: Installing slate roof shingles can cost thousands of dollars more than other types of shingles.
  • Heavy weight: Since the shingles are larger and heavier than other materials, you need to install additional framing to accommodate the extra weight. Keep in mind that some roof structures can't support this material.

Pros and Cons of Clay Shingles

Clay shingles can take on several different shapes. Consider the benefits of this shingle type to see if it's suitable for your home:

  • Durable: Clay is fireproof and resistant to fading and insect damage.
  • Energy efficient: Air circulates between the tiles and regulates your roof's temperature, potentially reducing your monthly utility bills.
  • Long lasting: When appropriately maintained, clay shingles can last up to a century on the top of your house.

You may also want to review the drawbacks of clay shingles:

  • Heavy: Like slate tiles, clay shingles often need additional framing to accommodate their weight.
  • Expensive: Clay shingles tend to cost thousands of dollars more than other types of shingles to purchase and install.
  • Vulnerable to impact damage: Each shingle is prone to suffer damage from objects that hit it.

Pros and Cons of Composite Shingles

As an alternative to natural materials, composite shingles feature polymer, rubber or plastic and provide the following advantages for your property:

  • Versatile design: Due to their various materials, you have a wide selection of color and style options. These shingles can look and feel like natural wood or slate shingles, depending on your design preference.
  • Inexpensive: Composite shingles are less expensive than clay, concrete and slate shingles.
  • Durable: Composite shingles can retain their color for more than half a century. They're resistant to heat and impact, and most high-end products can withstand fire and hail. The various additives within these shingles enhance their defense against moss buildup and UV damage.

Composite shingles also come with these drawbacks:

  • Not energy efficient: Even though they look like wood and slate shingles, composite shingles don't have the same insulating qualities as their natural counterparts.
  • Vulnerable to moisture damage: Composite shingles can accommodate installation in any climate, but some low-quality shingles can soak, freeze and warp in areas with colder temperatures.
  • New to the market: Since composite shingles are relatively new, it may be hard to find a contractor with the necessary experience to install them properly.
What kind of roof shigles are best for you roof?

What Kind of Shingles Are Best for Your Roof?

The experts at specialize in shingle roof replacement to provide the best coverage for your home. If you need a new roof, we partner with local contractors who have the necessary experience to install any shingle on your property.

Want to Discuss Your Roof?

We handle everything from start to finish
We handle insurance claims so you don't have to
We only hire the top 5% of roofing installers in the industry
We back every project with our Million Dollar Guarantee

Schedule a Free Roof Inspection

Ready to discuss your commercial roofing project? Please fill out the form below and we'll contact you within 24 hours.